Cakrawala Wawasan Kebangsaan employs a rigorous and objective peer review process to ensure the scientific quality and integrity of every manuscript published. Once a manuscript is submitted, the editor will conduct an initial check to ensure its suitability with the journal's scope and compliance with writing guidelines. Manuscripts that pass this initial stage will then undergo a double-blind peer review process, where the identities of the authors are unknown to the reviewers, and vice versa. This method is designed to minimize bias and ensure that the evaluation is based purely on scientific substance, originality, relevance, and research methodology. This process is crucial for maintaining high academic standards and ensuring that only quality research reaches publication.
Each pre-selected manuscript will be sent to at least two independent reviewers with expertise in the relevant field. These reviewers are responsible for evaluating key aspects of the manuscript, including the clarity of arguments, validity of methodology, significance of findings, and relevance of cited literature. They will also provide constructive feedback to help authors improve the quality of their manuscripts, both in terms of content and presentation. The editor will consider the reports from these reviewers to make a final decision: accept the manuscript without revisions, accept with minor or major revisions, or reject it. This entire process is conducted confidentially to protect the privacy of both authors and reviewers.
The primary goal of the peer review process at Cakrawala Wawasan Kebangsaan is to ensure that all published articles meet standards of scientific excellence. This not only serves as a quality filter but also as a mechanism to improve the quality of the research itself through expert feedback. The journal is committed to completing the peer review process efficiently and in a timely manner, while maintaining thoroughness. Transparency and integrity are the cornerstones of every stage of this process, ensuring that the scientific community can trust the validity and reliability of the research presented in Cakrawala Wawasan Kebangsaan.
