JEI : Jurnal Ekonomi Islam is a journal published by CV Media Jaza Utama.
KEPUTUSAN MENTERI HUKUM DAN HAK ASASI MANUSIA REPUBLIK INDONESIA
NOMOR AHU-00035.AH.02.02.TAHUN 2018
Sekretariat: Jl. Sersan Usman 60 Banaran Kertosono Kabupaten Nganjuk, Jawa Timur, 64311 Telp 0358 5502480. Email: admin@mjukn.org
Screening For Plagiarism
Screening for Plagiarism at the Journal of Islamic Economics
The Journal of Islamic Economics is unwavering in its commitment to publishing original and ethically sound research. A critical component of this commitment is our stringent plagiarism screening process, which is implemented for every manuscript submitted to the journal. We believe that maintaining academic integrity is paramount, and therefore, any form of plagiarism, including self-plagiarism, will lead to immediate rejection of the manuscript.
Our Approach to Plagiarism Detection
Upon submission, every manuscript undergoes an initial assessment, which includes a thorough plagiarism check. This process is conducted using industry-leading plagiarism detection software (e.g., Turnitin, iThenticate, or similar reputable tools). This software compares the submitted manuscript against a vast database of scholarly publications, including journal articles, books, conference papers, theses, dissertations, and web content.
The primary goal of this screening is to identify any instances of:
- Direct Plagiarism: verbatim copying of text without proper attribution.
- Mosaic Plagiarism: borrowing phrases or ideas from a source without proper attribution, often by changing a few words or phrases while maintaining the original sentence structure.
- Paraphrasing Plagiarism: rephrasing someone else's ideas or words without proper attribution.
- Self-Plagiarism (Text Recycling): reusing significant portions of one's own previously published work without proper citation or indication that the content has appeared elsewhere. While reusing parts of one's own work can be legitimate in some contexts (e.g., methodology sections in a series of related papers), it must always be clearly acknowledged and cited. Excessive or unacknowledged self-recycling is considered unethical.
- Data Fabrication/Falsification: Although not strictly plagiarism, this is a related form of academic misconduct. While our software primarily checks for text similarity, the overall ethical review process also considers the integrity of data.
The Screening Process
- Automated Check: As soon as a manuscript is submitted, it is uploaded to the plagiarism detection software. The software generates a similarity report, highlighting sections of the manuscript that match existing content in its database.
- Editorial Review of Similarity Report: The similarity report is then carefully reviewed by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated Associate Editor. A high similarity score does not automatically equate to plagiarism. The editor meticulously examines the highlighted sections to distinguish between properly cited quotations, common phrases, and legitimate references versus instances of unacknowledged borrowing. For example, a high similarity score in the reference list or common methodological descriptions might be acceptable, whereas high similarity in the introduction, literature review, or results sections would raise red flags.
- Decision Based on Findings:
- Minor Issues/Acceptable Similarity: If the similarity score is low and the highlighted matches are clearly attributable to proper citation or common academic phrasing, the manuscript proceeds to the next stage of the review process (e.g., peer review).
- Moderate Concerns: If the similarity report indicates moderate levels of unacknowledged text, the manuscript may be sent back to the authors with a request for significant revisions to address the plagiarism concerns and ensure proper attribution.
- Major Plagiarism/Serious Misconduct: If the similarity report reveals substantial unacknowledged material, clear intent to plagiarize, or signs of data fabrication, the manuscript will be immediately rejected. In severe cases, the authors' institutions may be notified, and they may face a ban from submitting to the Journal of Islamic Economics in the future.
By implementing this rigorous plagiarism screening process, the Journal of Islamic Economics aims to safeguard the integrity of scholarly communication, uphold ethical standards in research, and ensure that only original and properly attributed work is published, thereby fostering trust and reliability within the academic community.
